Mulch Matters: Wood Chips, Straw, and Living Mulches Compared

The Power of Mulch in Pacific Northwest Gardens

Mulch is the unsung hero of successful gardening. A simple layer of organic material on your soil surface conserves water, suppresses weeds, moderates soil temperature, and feeds your soil as it decomposes. In the Pacific Northwest, where our dry summers contrast sharply with wet winters, proper mulching can cut watering needs in half while improving soil health year after year.

Raised garden bed with vegetables
Mulched raised beds retain moisture better and require less frequent watering during our dry summers.

Benefits of Mulching

Water Conservation

Bare soil loses moisture rapidly to evaporation. A 2-4 inch layer of mulch can reduce water loss by 50% or more—crucial during our dry summers when irrigation becomes essential. Mulched gardens need watering less frequently, saving both time and water.

Weed Suppression

Mulch blocks light from reaching weed seeds, preventing germination. Seeds that do germinate in mulch are easy to pull since their roots grow in loose organic matter rather than compacted soil. A well-mulched garden requires far less weeding.

Temperature Moderation

Mulch insulates soil from temperature extremes. In summer, mulched soil stays cooler, protecting roots during heat waves. In winter, mulch moderates freeze-thaw cycles that heave plants out of the ground.

Soil Building

As organic mulches decompose, they add organic matter to soil, improving structure, water retention, and nutrient availability. Mulch feeds the soil organisms that create healthy, living soil.

Disease Prevention

Mulch prevents soil from splashing onto leaves during rain or watering—a major pathway for soil-borne diseases like tomato blight. This is particularly valuable in our rainy Pacific Northwest climate.

Types of Mulch for Pacific Northwest Gardens

Straw

One of the best mulches for vegetable gardens. Light, easy to spread, and breaks down in a single season, adding organic matter to soil.

  • Pros: Inexpensive, readily available, excellent for vegetables, breaks down completely
  • Cons: Can harbor slugs, may contain weed seeds if using hay instead of straw
  • Best uses: Vegetable gardens, pathways, around strawberries
  • Application: 3-6 inches; settles to about half that depth

Wood Chips

Long-lasting mulch ideal for permanent plantings. Arborist chips (mixed species from tree services) are often free and decompose more slowly than commercial chips.

  • Pros: Long-lasting (2-3 years), often free from tree services, attractive appearance
  • Cons: Can rob nitrogen from soil as it decomposes, not ideal for annual vegetables
  • Best uses: Trees, shrubs, perennial beds, pathways
  • Application: 3-4 inches, keeping clear of trunks and stems

Bark Mulch

Attractive, uniform appearance. Available in fine, medium, and large chip sizes. More expensive than arborist chips but more consistent.

  • Pros: Attractive, available in different colors and sizes, stays in place well
  • Cons: More expensive, may float away in heavy rain
  • Best uses: Ornamental beds, foundation plantings
  • Application: 2-3 inches for fine bark, 3-4 for larger chips

Leaves

Free and abundant in fall. Shred leaves before using—whole leaves mat and shed water. Excellent for adding organic matter.

  • Pros: Free, adds excellent organic matter, attracts earthworms
  • Cons: Must be shredded, can mat if wet, may blow away
  • Best uses: Vegetable gardens, perennial beds, around trees
  • Application: 3-4 inches shredded

Grass Clippings

Free source of nitrogen-rich organic matter. Use only untreated grass, apply in thin layers to prevent matting and odor.

  • Pros: Free, adds nitrogen, readily available
  • Cons: Can mat and smell if applied too thick, may contain herbicide residue
  • Best uses: Vegetable gardens, mixed with other materials
  • Application: 1-2 inches at a time; let dry before adding more

Compost

The premium mulch that also feeds plants. More expensive to use in thick layers, but excellent benefits.

  • Pros: Feeds soil and plants, improves soil structure, suppresses disease
  • Cons: Expensive in large quantities, may contain weed seeds if not fully composted
  • Best uses: Any garden area, especially around vegetables and perennials
  • Application: 1-2 inches; can be topped with other mulch

Living Mulch

Low-growing plants that cover soil between crops. In the Pacific Northwest, clover between rows or around perennials provides living mulch that also fixes nitrogen.

  • Pros: Adds nitrogen (legumes), provides pollinator habitat, permanent coverage
  • Cons: Competes with crops for water, requires management
  • Best uses: Orchards, established perennial beds, pathways

When and How to Apply Mulch

Spring Application

Wait until soil warms before mulching vegetable gardens—early mulching keeps soil cold and delays plant growth. In the Seattle area, wait until mid-May for warm-season crops.

For perennials and established plantings, apply mulch in early spring as growth begins. This suppresses weeds before they establish.

Fall Application

Apply mulch around perennials after the ground begins to freeze (usually December in the Pacific Northwest). This moderates freeze-thaw cycles and protects roots.

Spread fall leaves over vegetable beds to protect soil and add organic matter for spring.

Application Guidelines

  • Depth: 2-4 inches for most organic mulches
  • Keep away from stems: Leave 1-2 inches of clear space around plant stems and tree trunks to prevent rot
  • Don’t pile against bark: “Volcano mulching” (piling mulch against tree trunks) kills trees
  • Refresh as needed: Add mulch as it decomposes, usually annually for fast-decomposing types

Mulching Challenges in the Pacific Northwest

Slug Habitat

Mulch provides excellent slug hiding spots. In slug-prone gardens:

  • Use less moisture-retentive mulches (bark rather than straw)
  • Keep mulch thinner near vulnerable plants
  • Use slug control methods in mulched areas
  • Consider gravel or crushed shell around susceptible crops

Winter Wetness

Our wet winters can make heavily mulched soil too soggy. Avoid mulching right against plant crowns where moisture can cause rot. Some gardeners pull mulch back from perennial crowns in fall.

Nitrogen Draw-Down

Fresh wood products temporarily tie up soil nitrogen as they decompose. For vegetable gardens, either:

  • Use finished compost or straw instead of wood chips
  • Add nitrogen (blood meal, composted manure) when using wood mulch
  • Reserve wood chips for pathways and perennial areas

Mulching Specific Garden Areas

Vegetable Gardens

Straw is the classic choice. Apply 3-4 inches around established plants, keeping clear of stems. For tomatoes, mulch after soil warms to prevent disease splash.

Tomatoes growing on the vine
Mulching around tomatoes prevents soil splash that spreads blight—especially important in our wet climate.

Perennial Beds

Shredded bark or wood chips work well. Apply in spring, refresh annually. Avoid piling against plant crowns.

Trees and Shrubs

Create a mulch ring extending to the drip line (outer edge of branches), 3-4 inches deep. Keep mulch 6 inches from trunks—never pile against bark.

Pathways

Wood chips or coarse bark, 4-6 inches deep, create comfortable, weed-free paths. Arborist chips are often free and work excellently.

Strawberries

Straw is traditional (hence the name). Apply after ground freezes in fall to protect crowns, refresh in spring to keep berries clean.

Cost-Effective Mulching

Mulching a large garden can be expensive, but many materials are free or inexpensive:

  • Arborist chips: Tree services often give away chips free—check ChipDrop or call local arborists
  • Leaves: Collect from your yard and neighbors in fall
  • Grass clippings: Free from your lawn (untreated only)
  • Straw: Buy in fall when prices are lowest
  • Coffee grounds: Many coffee shops give away grounds free
  • Newspaper: Layer under other mulches for extra weed suppression

The Long-Term Benefits

Consistent mulching transforms gardens over time. After several years of annual mulching, you’ll notice:

  • Darker, richer soil full of organic matter
  • More earthworms and soil life
  • Improved water retention—less watering needed
  • Fewer weeds as soil seed bank depletes
  • Better plant growth with less fertilizer

Mulching is one of the simplest, most effective practices for Pacific Northwest gardens. Start with whatever materials you have available, and add mulching to your annual garden routine. Your soil—and your plants—will thank you.

Jason Michael

Jason Michael

Author & Expert

Jason Michael is a Pacific Northwest gardening enthusiast and longtime homeowner in the Seattle area. He enjoys growing vegetables, cultivating native plants, and experimenting with sustainable gardening practices suited to the region's unique climate.

36 Articles
View All Posts